Written by Robera BirosLynn Saternow of the Sharon Herald is something else. Back in the spring Lynn made the precious statement “Who in their right mind would vote for Roberta Biros for county treasurer”. It was an entertaining editorial considering the Herald claims that they are unbiased in their comments. I have a sense of humor and made the best of the comments. I’ve even joked with Lynn personally about it. No hard feelings, right? I figured that Lynn just had a momentary lapse of judgment.
Last weekend I had the realization that Lynn didn’t just have a lapse of judgment several months ago . . . no, I think that Lynn may just be plain stupid (sorry Lynn).
On Saturday, Lynn had an editorial titled “Palin’s book sparks satire and a stab at state politicos” (
READ HERE). In it he suggested that Mercer County voters should “fire” State Senator Bob Robbins, State Representative Dick Stevenson, State Representative Michele Brooks, and State Representative Mark Longietti due to the inability of the General Assembly to pass a State Budget. Lynn was so busy bloviating that he completely lost track of the facts. Painting with such a broad brush is just wrong, so I’d like to fill in the details for all of you . . . my loyal readers.
First, if he’d do his homework, Lynn would know that there is a hierarchy of blame for our lack of a budget. The finger pointing should start at the top and work its way down. Governor Rendell is at the top of the pyramid, the Republican leadership in the Senate comes up second, and the Democrat leadership in the House pulls up the rear. Are SOME of the names that Lynn mentioned worthy of blame? Sure. Should all of our legislators be fired? . . . that is simply ridiculous. Allow me to explain how each of our legislators is involved in the budget process.
Senator Bob Robbins
Senator Robbins is the Senate Republican Caucus Secretary. In the hierarchy of the Senate majority, he is #7. He is a supposed to be a high-ranking official. Is he ineffective? Yes. Has he been in too long? Yes. He keeps a low profile in hopes of squeaking through another re-election in 2010 after nearly being kicked to the curb in 2006 after his involvement in the “pay raise” fiasco. Senator Robbin’s days are numbered, and his inability to step up as a leader in Harrisburg is proof of that.
Senator Robbins HAS power, but he hasn’t used it to LEAD during the budget crisis. Does he deserve to be ‘fired’ because of his lack of action in the budget negotiations? I think so, but that is just my personal opinion.
Representative Dick Stevenson
While Rep. Stevenson is simply a member of the rank and file in the House of Representatives, he has a direct relationship with the budget fiasco in that he is on the Appropriations Committee. The Appropriations Committee controlled the budget since May of this year, and they can easily be blamed for our lack of a budget now. Rep. Stevenson’s power in the committee is limited as the Republican Party is in the minority in the House and it should be noted that he is not part of the leadership in the committee. He has had a front row seat to the excitement (or lack thereof) in the budget battle, but he is not necessarily to blame.
Does he deserve to be ‘fired’ because of his lack of action in the budget negotiations? Although he has a front row seat, I don’t think Rep. Stevenson holds blame in this situation. He may be a bit ineffective, but he doesn’t deserve to be fired because of it.
Representatives Mark Longietti and Michele BrooksReps. Longietti and Brooks are simply members of the rank and file in the state legislature. They have been waiting all summer for a budget to vote on, and they have been as disappointed as we are. They are both young, focused, and driven to appropriately represent their constituents. They will both become more effective as they work their way up in the ranks.
Do they deserve to be ‘fired” because of their lack of action in the budget negotiations? Not by a long shot. While Lynn shows an obvious lack of originality by throwing a shot at Michele Brooks, he demonstrates some level of insanity by taking on Mark Longietti. Lynn is not the first person to criticize the “love/hate” relationship that some have with Rep. Brooks; but Rep. Longietti has no problem with the “love/love” relationships that he has with his constituents. To openly state that Rep. Longietti needs to be fired falls under the category of “fightin’ words”. I can only compare it to spray-painting the words “egg my house” on your garage door a few days before Halloween.
Perhaps Lynn’s only purpose in writing his weekly columns is to annoy the readers in the valley. He demonstrated that this spring, and he is reinforcing his commitment with his latest rant. If that is the case . . . keep up the good work. You are doing a fine job, Lynn.
In Closing . . .According to the press (and press releases from ‘some’ legislators), the budget process may be moving forward.
EXAMPLE ONE: On October 6, Senator Bob Robbins posted a press release to his website (although he did not send out an email message to his constituents) stating “Senate Sends Responsible Budget Package to House” [READ HERE].
EXAMPLE TWO: Similarly, Rep. Mark Longietti published a press release on his website (again no email) stating that he had “voted to approve the budget” [READ HERE and HERE].
EXAMPLE THREE: Today, The Herald printed a small story titled Pa. Lawmakers Could Get Budget Today. It was a short story, but the title summarized the content and the view from the Governor's Office.
OTHER EXAMPLES?: Unfortunately, Representatives Michele Brooks and Dick Stevenson have made not official announcements by email or through their websites regarding the current status of the budget battle.
While the legislator announcements and newspaper “snippets” are useful, I’d prefer to do a little research on my own. A quick review of PennsylvaniaVotes.org shows that a budget DID pass the Pennsylvania House of Representatives on Wednesday, October 7th, but it passed strictly along a party-line vote . . . again. There may be a budget moving along, but it is not one that looks potentially non-partisan. CLICK HERE to see the details of the October 7th budget vote. I have a bad feeling . . . and I truthfully HOPE THAT I’M WRONG . . . but I predict that they can paint a shiny smiley face on this, but the budget problems in Harrisburg may be far from over.
As always, just my opinion.
.